Summer pruning seems to create a lot of confusion.
We reckon that rather than get caught up with figuring out the perfect time to prune, it’s easier to remember the mantra that there’s no “right” or “wrong”, there’s just cuts and consequences.
This approach takes the pressure off so you can feel like you can have a go, which is when the real learning starts.
How will your trees respond if you prune them in summer?
Pruning your tree in summer tends to result in a smaller growth response from the tree.
On the other hand, pruning your fruit tree while it’s dormant in winter is more likely to encourage the tree to grow strongly in response.
Once you understand those principles, it becomes obvious that pruning in summer might suit a really big tree that you’re trying to renovate, for example.
Whereas winter is clearly the best time to prune young trees that you want to encourage to grow big and strong (and then become fruitful) as quickly as possible.
Do pruning “rules” work?
We’re not big fans of rules when it comes to pruning — we find they actually confuse people. Rules can also lead to inexperienced pruners making cuts that can have less than ideal consequences.
It’s much better to understand the principles behind pruning. Then you can fall back on them to make up your mind about when to prune.
Our Foolproof 7-step pruning method is based on 10 pruning principles, but the two that are most relevant here are #3: prune in winter to encourage growth, and #4: trim your trees in summer to slow growth.
Without getting too deeply into the physiological reasons behind these principles in this blog, you can use them to have a think about when you might want to either encourage vigour (i.e. vegetative growth) in your tree and when you might want to slow growth down a bit.
And remember, they’re just principles — they just tell you what’s more likely to happen. There’s very few definites in the wonderful world of fruit growing!
Summer pruning pros and cons
Some other things to think about in deciding whether to prune in summer are:
- disease — pruning in warm weather helps the cuts to heal quickly and reduce the introduction or spread of disease,
- fruit quality — reducing leaf canopy with summer pruning can reduce the size and sugar content of the fruit,
- fruit colour — less leaves allows better sun penetration to the tree and higher coloured fruit,
- sunburn — a bushy leaf canopy can provide protection to vulnerable fruit,
- root health — summer pruning can reduce root growth in a tree,
- ease of pruning — it’s much easier to see what you’re doing in winter when there are no leaves on the tree.
So for example, pruning a fruit tree in summer while it still has fruit can have a very different outcome to pruning it after harvest.
So rather than stressing too much about when is the right time to prune, just remember that it doesn’t really matter.
You’ll just get different consequences from doing it at different times of year.
And what a great way to learn!
If you really think about when to prune and why, and then pay attention to what happens as a result (pro tip: take before and after shots), you’ll become quite an experienced pruner surprisingly quickly.
If you still feel you need some help making the decision, take our Summer Pruning Short Course first.